10 Most Rewatchable Crime Movies of the 2010s, Ranked (2024)

Nothing makes a plot better than an unexpected, well-timed twist. For the crime genre, an unforeseen bait-and-switch is crucial in making viewers walk away feeling not only that their time was well-spent, but that they couldn't possibly have seen that plot change coming. The 2010s were a fantastic time for crime films that did just this, with viewers in awe of what they missed and wanting to go back and investigate the film further.

The decade boasts a ton of great films that were big successes both with audiences and at the box office. With the genre including acting performances by the likes of Gary Oldman, Emily Blunt, Ryan Gosling, Rosamund Pike, and Margot Robbie, and direction by talents like MartinScorsese, David Fincher, Rian Johnson, and Steven Soderbergh, here are the most rewatchable films of the 2010s.

10 'The Girl on the Train' (2016)

Directed by Tate Taylor

Based on the novel by Paula Hawkins, The Girl on the Train was a highly anticipated film when it was released in 2016, and it quickly became a hit at the box office, grossing $173 million worldwide. Directed by Tate Taylor (The Help), the film tells the story of Rachel (Emily Blunt), a recent divorcee struggling to part ways with her past. When she becomes obsessed with watching a house and its occupants on her morning commute, her life begins to unravel in ways she could've never imagined.

Girl on the Train is captivating due to its unreliable narrator: a woman who struggles with drinking and memory loss, beautifully played by Blunt (Fall Guy). The story is complex and layered in its narrative, and demands a rewatch after its wild and unpredictable ending, so that viewers can go back and see what pieces of Rachel's story they believe.

The Girl on the Train

R

Release Date

October 5, 2016

Director

Tate Taylor

Cast

Rebecca Ferguson , Emily Blunt , Edgar Ramirez , Justin Theroux , Haley Bennett , Luke Evans

Runtime

112

Main Genre

Thriller

Tagline

What you see can hurt you.

WATCH ON PRIME

9 'I, Tonya' (2017)

Directed by Craig Gillespie

Based on the true 1994 assault of Nancy Kerrigan, I, Tonya was written for the screen by Steven Rogers and stars Margot Robbie as figure skater Tonya Harding, the woman responsible for the hit on fellow skater Kerrigan. The film follows Tonya up until the events in a mockumentary, black comedy style, with creative directing by Craig Gillespie (Lars and the Real Girl).

I, Tonya is a masterclass in acting, with leads Robbie, Sebastian Stan, Allison Janney, and Julianne Nicholson giving show-stopping performances as their real-life counterparts. With anAcademy Award-winning performance from Janney,I, Tonya is a joy to rewatch, as its sure to spark debate over how much guilt each character involved deserves in the chaos that ensues. Perhaps viewers can even use their second viewing of I, Tonya to take an acting lesson by studying the incredible performances of its cast.

I, Tonya

R

Release Date

January 19, 2018

Director

Craig Gillespie

Cast

Margot Robbie , Sebastian Stan , Allison Janney , Julianne Nicholson , Paul Walter Hauser , Bobby Cannavale

Runtime

119 minutes

Main Genre

Biography

Tagline

Fitting in is overrated

WATCH ON MAX

8 'Side Effects' (2013)

Directed by Steven Soderbergh

Steven Soderbergh (Behind the Candelabra)'s 2013 crime film, Side Effects tells the story of a young woman named Emily (Rooney Mara) who is put on new medication that causes her to act in strange ways. When Emily's husband Martin (Channing Tatum) gets killed, all eyes are on Emily and her new pills.

Side Effects has such a twisted ending that it demands a second watch. During the first viewing of the film, the performances of each actor may appear deceivingly subtle; however, it becomes clear upon a second look that this subtlety is actually calculation on the part of the characters and their motivations. Looking at the film through each character's individual experience will have viewers feeling like the investigators of Martin's death.

Side Effects

R

Release Date

February 7, 2013

Director

Steven Soderbergh

Cast

Rooney Mara , Carmen Pelaez , Marin Ireland , Channing Tatum , Polly Draper , Haraldo Alvarez

Runtime

100

Main Genre

Crime

Tagline

One pill can change your life.

WATCH ON APPLE TV

7 'The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo' (2011)

Directed by David Fincher

Based on the best-selling book by Stieg Larson, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo follows disgraced journalist Mikael (Daniel Craig) as he attempts to get his career back on track by figuring out what happened to a young woman who disappeared forty years prior. With the help of an intelligent hacker (Rooney Mara), Mikael gets into the mystery deeper than he ever thought he would.

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo has a lot of going for it: incredible directing by David Fincher (Zodiac), fantastic acting by its cast, and a heart-pounding plot that will leave audiences on the edge of their seats. The film was a triumph at the box office, grossing $232 million worldwide, and earning five Academy Award nominations, winning for Best Editing. The plot of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is much more complex than it initially seems, and a second watch allows for details of the crimes and who the true villain is to be better noticed by the viewer.

The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo (2011)

R

Release Date

December 14, 2011

Director

David Fincher

Cast

Daniel Craig , Rooney Mara , Robin Wright , Stellan Skarsgård , Christopher Plummer , Joely Richardson

Runtime

160

Main Genre

Crime

WATCH ON PRIME

6 'All Good Things' (2010)

Directed by Andrew Jareki

Andrew Jareki's All Good Things is a true-crime fan's dream. Based on the chilling true story of real estate mogul Robert Durst and his descent into madness and murder, the film stars Ryan Gosling (Drive) as Durst and Kirsten Dunst (Spider-Man) as his late wife, Kathy, who mysteriously disappeared in the 1980s.

While Durst's life events are dramatized in All Good Things, Jareki's directorial style perfectly tells the heartbreaking story of Kathy and her attempts to have a life with Durst. The way the tension is slowly ticked up as the film goes on, coupled with the acting performances by Gosling, Dunst, Frank Langella, Lily Rabe, and Kristen Wiig are fantastic. A rewatch of the film became mandatory viewing after the release of Jareki's two-part Durst documentary, The Jinx, a film that was born out of the opinions Jareki expressed about Robert Durst in All Good Things. Taking a look back at All Good Films, the movie that ultimately led to the imprisonment of Durst, is just as thrilling as the plot of the film.

All Good Things

R

Release Date

December 3, 2010

Director

Andrew Jarecki

Cast

Ryan Gosling , Kirsten Dunst , Frank Langella , Lily Rabe , Philip Baker Hall , Michael Esper

Runtime

120

Main Genre

Drama

Tagline

The perfect love story, until it became the perfect crime.

WATCH ON PEAco*ck

5 'Knives Out' (2019)

Directed by Rian Johnson

Rian Johnson's Knives Out stars Daniel Craig (Casino Royale) as Benoit Blanc, the sassy detective sent to investigate the death of mystery writer Harlan Thrombley (Christopher Plumber). Little does Blanc know that in taking on the case, he is diving into the chaos that is the Thrombley family, all of whom are greedy for the massive fortune their relative left behind.

Knives Out is a spectacle, with fast-paced storytelling and hilariously dark writing by Johnson, and a fabulous and fitting musical score by Nathan Johnson. The audience becomes detective Benoit Blanc when they rewatch the film, seeing the tiny details he was able to notice the first time around. Once the true killer of Knives Out is revealed, audiences won't be able to help but take a second look at all the clues they missed.

Knives Out

PG-13

Release Date

November 27, 2019

Director

Rian Johnson

Cast

Toni Collette , Ana De Armas , Chris Evans , Katherine Langford , Jaeden Martell , Edi Patterson , Daniel Craig

Runtime

130 minutes

Main Genre

Mystery

WATCH ON APPLE TV

4 'Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy' (2011)

Directed by Tomas Alfredson

Three-time Academy Award nominee Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy follows espionage veteran George Smiley (Gary Oldman) as he is reluctantly pulled out of retirement in order to find a Soviet Agent hiding within MI6. Co-starring Mark Strong, and John Hurt, the film is a slow-burn with a big payoff in the end.

Audiences will feel just like George Smiley as they attempt to solve the mystery of who the odd man out of the group is. It's incredibly difficult to figure out, and it's not until the final moments of the film that the viewer is clued in on the mystery. A second watch allows fans to appreciate the complexity of the script, the well-thought-out production design by Maria Djurkovic (The Imitation Game) and the direction by Tomas Alfredson (Let The Right One In), which makes figuring out whodunnit so hard to do.

Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy

R

Release Date

September 16, 2011

Director

Tomas Alfredson

Cast

Gary Oldman , Colin Firth , Tom Hardy , Mark Strong , Ciarán Hinds , Benedict Cumberbatch , Toby Jones , John Hurt

Runtime

127

Main Genre

Thriller

WATCH ON PRIME

3 'Shutter Island' (2010)

Directed by Martin Scorsese

Martin Scorsese's Shutter Island stars Leonardo DiCaprio and Mark Ruffalo as two United States marshals who are sent to an asylum on a remote island to investigate the disappearance of one of its patients. Co-starring the incredible Ben Kingsley, Michelle Williams, and Emily Mortimer, the acting performances are just as good as the wild tale.

With one of the best plot twists imaginable, Shutter Island doesn't just require a second look, but a third, fourth, and fifth. The reveal of the film's true meaning, as well as where the missing patient is, is astonishing. The viewer's reaction will be to start the film over immediately, and to take the story from the perspective of each character they may not have thought twice about in their initial watch.

Shutter Island

R

Release Date

February 14, 2010

Director

Martin Scorsese

Cast

Leonardo DiCaprio , Mark Ruffalo , Ben Kingsley , Max Von Sydow , Michelle Williams , Emily Mortimer

Runtime

138 minutes

Main Genre

Drama

Tagline

Someone is missing.

WATCH ON APPLE TV

2 'Gone Girl' (2014)

Directed by David Fincher

Based on the best-selling novel by Gillian Flynn, Gone Girl follows Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck) as he searches for his missing wife, Amy (Rosamund Pike). It's not long before Nick is the number one suspect in her disappearance, and he is forced to take drastic measures to find out the truth.

Gone Girl plays out like a heart-pounding movie trailer, with constant movement that makes the two-and-a-half-hour film go by in the blink of an eye. With an unbelievable revelation midway through the film, it's fun to go back and see what was missed in the first half, and to wonder if solving the crime in real life would've been possible. More than that, figuring out whose side you're on in the mess of Nick and Amy is an added maze to figure out, as no one is as innocent as they appear.

Gone Girl

R

Release Date

October 3, 2014

Director

David Fincher

Cast

Ben Affleck , Rosamund Pike , Neil Patrick Harris , Tyler Perry , Carrie Coon , Kim Dickens

Runtime

149 minutes

Main Genre

Drama

Tagline

You don't know what you've got 'til it's...

WATCH ON PRIME

1 'Nightcrawler' (2014)

Directed by Dan Gilroy

Nightcrawler, written and directed by Dan Gilroy (Andor), follows con artist Louis Bloom (Jake Gyllenhaal) as he weasles his way into a job as a night journalist. Following every siren he hears in the moonlit streets of Los Angeles, Louis slowly becomes a part of his own true-crime story as the lines between his life and the news are blurred.

Gyllenhaal's extraordinary performance perfectly depicts a man as he becomes something else; a tricky feat to portray within the time frame of a film. Gilroy's directing is spectacular, with viewers being taken along for the fast-paced ride as if they are in the news van with Louis. Because of the artful direction, heart-racing pacing, and brilliant editing of Nightcrawler, watching the film a second time allows one to better understand Louis and his descent into hysteria.

WATCH ON APPLE TV